Have Some Salt with that Creatine

 

I saw a social media post that stated adding salt to your creatine helps with absorption into muscle tissue so I decided to do a bit of research to determine if that was true. The answer is, “Yes, but...”

Yes, the scientific consensus suggests that adding salt (sodium) to creatine can help with creatine uptake in the muscle. However, iresearchers often study this in conjunction with carbohydrates or other electrolytes.

Here is a summary of the mechanism and evidence:

1. The Role of Sodium in Creatine Transport

Creatine is not simply absorbed passively by your muscle cells; it requires a specific transport mechanism.

• Sodium-Dependent Transporter: The creatine transporter protein (CreaT1), responsible for transporting creatine from the bloodstream into the muscle cell, is a sodium- and chloride-dependent symporter.

• Co-Transport: This means that the creatine molecule is actively transported into the cell along with sodium ions (and chloride ions). The high concentration gradient of sodium outside the cell is what provides the energy to drive creatine into the muscle.

• Enhanced Uptake: Studies have shown that creatine uptake into muscle cells is increased when the concentrations of sodium and chloride in the surrounding fluid are elevated.

2. Practical Implications

While the mechanism supports the idea of sodium aiding uptake, the most common and effective way to maximize creatine absorption involves one of two things, both of which are related to sodium:

Strategy	Mechanism
Co-Ingestion with Carbohydrates	The consumption of large amounts of simple carbohydrates (like dextrose or fruit juice) causes an insulin spike. Insulin is known to stimulate the sodium-potassium (Na$^+$-K$^+$) pump on the muscle cell membrane. This pump's activity helps maintain the sodium gradient, which in turn enhances the activity of the sodium-dependent creatine transporter.
Adding a Small Amount of Salt	Adding a small amount of salt (sodium chloride) directly can increase the sodium concentration, theoretically providing more "fuel" for the sodium-dependent creatine transporter. Some sports nutritionists recommend a small dose (e.g., $200$ to $500\text{ mg}$ of sodium) with a post-training meal for this purpose.

In summary, the science shows that the creatine transporter relies on a sodium gradient, making the presence of sodium essential and an increase in its concentration beneficial for maximizing muscle creatine stores.

Dampening the Insulin Spike

You don’t like insulin spikes, you say. Well, it turns out that combine the sugary carbs with protein provides similar results. The combined intake of carbohydrates (CHO) and protein dramatically enhances creatine uptake through a synergistic process primarily mediated by the hormone insulin.

Here is a breakdown of how each component and its combination influence muscle creatine uptake:

---

1. The Primary Driver: Insulin (Stimulated by Carbohydrates)

The most well-established way to enhance creatine uptake is by creating a significant spike in insulin levels, which is primarily achieved by ingesting simple carbohydrates.

Factor	Mechanism of Action	Outcome for Creatine
Simple Carbohydrates	Fast-digesting carbohydrates (like dextrose, maltodextrin, or fruit juice) cause a rapid release of a large amount of insulin from the pancreas.	Essential for Max Uptake: High insulin levels enhance the activity of the muscle's sodium-potassium pump (Na$^+$-K$^+$ ATPase), which helps to maintain the strong sodium gradient outside the cell. Since the creatine transporter (CreaT1) is sodium-dependent, an optimized sodium gradient essentially "super-charges" the transporter, driving more creatine into the muscle cell.
Insulin Dose Required	Studies have shown that insulin must be present at physiologically high or supraphysiological concentrations to significantly enhance creatine accumulation. This required a huge dose of pure carbohydrates (around $90\text{ to }100\text{ grams}$) when taken alone.	Creatine retention in the muscle can be substantially increased (by up to 60%) when combined with a large amount of simple carbohydrates.

2. The Synergistic Boost: Protein

Adding protein to the creatine/carbohydrate mixture offers an advantage by reducing the massive amount of carbohydrates needed.

Factor	Mechanism of Action	Outcome for Creatine
Carbohydrate + Protein Mix	When protein (specifically specific amino acids) is ingested along with carbohydrates, it can lead to a greater or more prolonged insulin response than either macronutrient would produce alone.	Reduced Carbohydrate Need: Research has shown that a mixture of creatine with a smaller, more practical dose of both carbohydrate (~50g) and protein (~50g) is as effective at potentiating insulin release and creatine retention as ingesting creatine with ~100g of carbohydrates alone.

Summary of the Influence

The recommendation to take creatine with carbs and protein is a strategy to trigger a robust insulin response, which is the key hormonal signal that enhances the activity of the sodium-dependent creatine transporter. This strategy makes the insulin-mediated augmentation of muscle creatine accumulation a more feasible option for athletes than trying to consume $100\text{ grams}$ of pure sugar several times a day.

Consistency Is Key

The current research suggests a clear conclusion about creatine timing: consistency is far more important than the exact time of day, but taking it close to your workout may offer a slight advantage.

Here is a breakdown of the standard recommendations and the rationale behind them:

1. The Most Important Factor: Consistency

• Muscle Saturation: Creatine works by saturating your muscle cells with phosphocreatine over days and weeks. Once your muscles are saturated, the benefits (increased strength, mass, power) are locked in. An acute dose before a workout will not immediately boost performance.

• Daily Dosing: The consensus is to take the daily maintenance dose (typically $3\text{ to }5\text{ grams}$) every day, including rest days, to maintain high muscle creatine levels. Missing doses causes intramuscular concentrations to fall.

• Recommendation: Take it at a time that is easiest to remember and stick to it consistently.

---

2. Close to the Workout is Generally Recommended

While the difference is often slight, most researchers agree that taking creatine shortly before or shortly after a workout is better than taking it at a time far removed from exercise (e.g., first thing in the morning and last thing at night).

Timing Option	Rationale / Proposed Benefit	Research Finding
Pre-Workout	Increased Blood Flow (Hyperemia): Exercise significantly increases blood flow to the working muscles. If creatine is taken $1\text{ to }2\text{ hours}$ before, its concentration in the blood will peak right as blood flow is highest, potentially maximizing delivery to the muscle cells.	Studies show that pre-workout supplements are highly effective at increasing muscle mass and strength.
Post-Workout	Cellular Readiness: Exercise depletes muscle glycogen and creates a metabolic environment where muscle cells may be more "receptive" to nutrient uptake, including an enhanced sensitivity to insulin.	Postworkout creatine may lead to slightly greater increases in lean mass and strength compared to pre-workout timing.
Both Pre- & Post-	Maximizes the probability of co-ingesting creatine when blood flow is high and cellular machinery is primed.	Research where supplements (including creatine, carbs, and protein) were taken immediately pre- and post-workout showed greater gains in muscle and strength than when taken at alternate times of the day.

Conclusion on Timing

• Take it Close: The overall best recommendation is to take your daily dose shortly before or shortly after your workout on training days.

• Take it with Carbs/Protein: To significantly boost the uptake process, combine your dose with the insulin-spiking combination of carbohydrates and protein.

• Rest Days: The timing on rest days is not critical; the goal is simply to maintain saturation. Take it with a meal to aid absorption.

Conclusion

I love creatine for its many benefits with just one of those being its effect on resistance training. In my opinion, all of these points are nibbling at the edges and pale in comparison to consistency in training. Can creatine help? Absolutely. Will it help if you don’t have a regular workout regime and good nutrition? Not so much. 

Just remember, I’m not a medical professional. All this advice was combed through the internet so please do your own research and consult with a trusted medical professional on anything presented here. 

Happy lifting.